pages 146 to 149
- Four student councils, each working like a different model of democracy.
| Team | How it works | Which model it resembles |
|---|---|---|
| Team A | All students gather and elect a president once a year, but the president has very limited powers. For major decisions they gather and vote using ballot papers | Direct democracy - the students decide themselves |
| Team B | Every class elects a representative; the representatives elect the Council President, and together they make decisions | Parliamentary democracy - the executive comes from the elected body |
| Team C | Students directly vote for the President and the Council members; the President is the chief decision-maker | Presidential democracy - the executive is elected directly |
| Team D | Only selected candidates may contest, the President holds most power, the Council has little authority and opposition is discouraged | Not a democracy - no real choice and no checks |
- The model names in the last column are not given in the book.
- The chapter only says these examples show that systems differ in how power is shared, who participates in decision-making , and whether checks and balances are in place.
- Each model is explained below.
- Team A - every student has a direct say, but this becomes slow and impractical as numbers grow.
- Team B - everyone is represented through their class, decisions are shared between the President and representatives, and it works at any size.
- Team C - the President has a direct mandate from all students, but a great deal of power sits with one person.
- Team D should be rejected.
- Elections happen, but only selected candidates can contest.
- Opposition is discouraged.
- So there is no real choice and no check on power .
- The main lesson: an election happening is not enough .
- What matters is whether there is genuine choice, shared decision-making, and checks and balances.
- Citizens directly participate in most decision-making processes.
- Some features of representative democracy also exist.
- Difficult to follow in large countries .
- Example: Switzerland .
- Also called Indirect Democracy .
- People elect their representatives .
- People do not directly govern .
- Periodic elections are held.
- The government is accountable to the people .
- Example: India .
- Representative democracy is of two kinds - Parliamentary and Presidential .
- Members of the Executive are also part of the legislature.
- The Executive is accountable to the legislature .
- People elect the legislature but not the executive.
- Examples: India and Canada .
- The Executive is independent of the legislature .
- The President is elected by the people.
- The President is accountable to the people .
- Example: United States of America .
| Country | Type of Democracy | System of Government | Head of State / Head of Government | Key Features |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| India | Representative (Parliamentary) | Executive power lies with the council of ministers headed by the Prime Minister | President (Head of State), Prime Minister (Head of Government) | Multi-party democracy, Written constitution, Fundamental Rights and Duties, Federalism |
| Canada | Representative (Parliamentary) | Executive power lies with the Prime Minister | Governor-General appointed by the Monarch (Head of State) on the advice of the Prime Minister (Head of Government) | Federalism, multi-party system |
| United Kingdom | Representative (Parliamentary Democracy with Constitutional Monarchy) | In a Constitutional Monarchy, the executive power lies with the Prime Minister | Monarch (Head of State), Prime Minister (Head of Government) | Unwritten constitution, parliamentary Sovereignty, multi-party system |
| Switzerland | Direct Democracy | Executive power lies with the Federal Council | The President is the Head of the Government | Written constitution with multiple parties |
| United States of America | Representative (Presidential Democracy) | Executive power lies with the President | The President is the Head of the Government | Written constitution, with two major parties |
- Note the pattern: India, Canada and the UK separate the Head of State from the Head of Government.
- Switzerland and the USA do not .
- Because the characteristics and features of democracy vary from country to country .
- Different societies institutionalise democracy in diverse ways , depending on:
- how citizens participate in decision-making
- how political power is structured
- Some involve direct citizen participation , others function through elected representatives .
- Yes.
- Certain fundamental principles are common to every democracy:
- freedom
- equality
- participation
- rule of law
- rights and duties
- So the models differ , but the principles stay the same .
- Choose any two of India's neighbouring countries and find out:
- Does the country hold regular elections ?
- Who chooses the Head of the Government ?
- Is there more than one political party ?
- How much freedom do citizens have to express their opinions and criticise the government?
| Country | Regular elections? | Who chooses the Head of Government | More than one party? | Freedom to criticise | Description |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Afghanistan | No | Taliban leadership, since 2021 | No parties | Very restricted | Non-democratic |
| Bangladesh | Yes - general election held February 2026 | Elected Parliament; PM from the majority party | Yes | Broadly free, still recovering after the 2024 upheaval | Democratic |
| Bhutan | Yes | Elected National Assembly; PM from the majority party, under a constitutional monarchy | Yes | Generally free | Democratic |
| China | No competitive national elections | The Communist Party of China; Premier confirmed by the National People's Congress | One ruling party | Heavily restricted | Non-democratic |
| Maldives | Yes | President elected directly by the people | Yes | Generally free | Democratic |
| Myanmar | Election held Dec 2025 to Jan 2026, but opposition parties excluded and civil war continuing | Military-backed leadership | Only approved parties | Very restricted | Non-democratic |
| Nepal | Yes - election held March 2026 after the 2025 protests | Elected Parliament; PM from the majority | Yes | Generally free | Democratic |
| Pakistan | Yes | Elected National Assembly; PM from the majority | Yes | Limited - press and opposition face pressure | Partially democratic |
| Sri Lanka | Yes | President elected directly; PM from Parliament | Yes | Generally free | Democratic |
- Link back to Fig.
- 6.5: Team D also held elections, but only selected candidates could contest and opposition was discouraged.
- Elections alone do not settle the question - Myanmar is the real-world version of Team D.
- This table is not from the NCERT chapter , which deliberately leaves the classification to the student.
- Political situations change quickly - Bangladesh, Myanmar and Nepal have all held elections since this book was printed.
- Always check current sources and quote the year of your information.
Show answer
Because citizens directly participate in most decision-making, which becomes impractical when the population is very large.
Show answer
In a parliamentary democracy the executive is part of the legislature. It is accountable to the legislature. In a presidential democracy the executive is independent of the legislature. The President is elected by the people and accountable to them.
Show answer
Switzerland - direct democracy. The United States of America - presidential democracy.
Show answer
The President is the Head of State; the Prime Minister is the Head of Government.
Show answer
The United Kingdom.