Check sibling questions

(a) List any three observations which posed a challenge to Mendeleev’s Periodic Law.

(b) How does the metallic character of elements vary on moving from

(i) left to right in a period,

(ii) From top to bottom in a period of the Modern Periodic Table? Given reason for your answer.




Mendeleev’s periodic law states that the chemical properties of an element are the periodic function of their atomic mass.

The challenges posed due to this were:

  1. Since isotopes have the same atomic number but different mass number, it could not be decided if they should be placed in the same slot or not.
  2. The increase in atomic mass of the elements was very irregular .
  3. The position of the H atom could not be decided.



(i) As we move from left to right in a period, the effective nuclear charge increases because of which the electrons are held tightly by the nucleus. So, it becomes difficult for an atom to donate electrons therefore, metallic character decreases .

(ii) As we move down the group, the atomic size increases as the number of shells increases . So the force with which the nucleus is holding electrons also decreases and it becomes easier for the atom to donate electrons, therefore, metallic character increases .

CA Maninder Singh's photo - Expert in Practical Accounts, Taxation and Efiling

Made by

CA Maninder Singh

CA Maninder Singh is a Chartered Accountant for the past 12 years and a teacher from the past 16 years. He teaches Science, Accounts and English at Teachoo