Check sibling questions

Study the data of the following three categories A. B and C.




Name of the element and Atomic Mass

Checking triad


  • Li (Atomic mass = 7)
  • Na (Atomic mass = 23)
  • K (Atomic mass = 39)

Mean of first and last = (7 + 39)/2 = 23

Atomic mass of middle = 23

Since they are the same , it is a dobereiner’s triad.


  • N (Atomic mass = 14)
  • P (Atomic mass = 31)
  • As (Atomic mass = 74)

Mean of first and last = (14 + 74)/2 = 44

Atomic mass of middle = 31

Since they are not the same , it is not a dobereiner’s triad.


  • B (Atomic mass = 10.8)
  • Al (Atomic mass = 27)
  • Ga (Atomic mass = 69.7)

Mean of first and last = (10.8 + 69.7)/2 = 40.25

Atomic mass of middle = 27

Since they are not the same , it is not a dobereiner’s triad.

Therefore, category 3 is a dobereiner’s triad.

Why did Mendeleev place elements of category  A, B and C in three different groups? 

  • Mendeleev arranged the elements according to  
  1. increasing atomic masses   
  2. The elements having similar chemical properties were placed together 
  • The elements of category A, B and C are similar among themselves ( have similar chemical properties ) but each category is different from each other.

Therefore, category A,B and C were placed in different groups.


Is Newland law of octaves applicable to all the three categories ? Give reason to justify your answer.

  • In newlands law of octave, the first and eighth elements show similar properties
  • This rule is not valid for elements after Ca in the periodic table. Therefore, the newland’s law of octave is not applicable for all the three categories.

Learn in your speed, with individual attention - Teachoo Maths 1-on-1 Class

Ask a doubt
Maninder Singh's photo - Co-founder, Teachoo

Made by

Maninder Singh

CA Maninder Singh is a Chartered Accountant for the past 13 years and a teacher from the past 17 years. He teaches Science, Economics, Accounting and English at Teachoo