Which of the following, in Fig. 9.18, correctly represents Cl⁻ ion (Atomic number of chlorine = 17).
View Answer
- Cl⁻ has gained one electron: 17 + 1 = 18 electrons .
- Configuration must be 2, 8, 8 (a complete octet).
- The correct diagram is the one showing shells filled as 2, 8, 8.
Diagram (Fig. 9.18)
Electron count → verdict
(i)
Shows 17 electrons (2, 8, 7) —
Wrong
. That is a neutral Cl atom.
(ii)
Shows
18
electrons (2, 8, 8) —
Correct
. Cl⁻ gains one electron.
(iii)
Electron count does not give a complete octet —
Wrong
.
(iv)
Only 2, 8 shells shown —
Wrong
. Too few electrons for chlorine.