HAR DATT : And does it have a short tail?
MERCHANT : (Astonished) You describe it perfectly! Yes, it has a short tail.
DEV DATT : Tell me, sir, has it not been suffering from a pain in the stomach?
MERCHANT : (Taken aback) How could you possibly know that? The poor creature has been unwell for two weeks now. Surely you are a healer! I will gladly pay your fee if you can cure it. But tell me, where is my camel?
RAM DATT : We regret to inform you that we do not know where it is.
  • Har Datt asks whether the camel has a short tail. The Merchant says he is correct.
  • Dev Datt then asks whether the camel has stomach pain. The Merchant again says yes.
  • The Merchant is so surprised that he thinks Dev Datt may be a person who can treat illness.
  • But when he asks where the camel is, Ram Datt says that they do not know.
  • This is where the Merchant’s surprise begins to turn into doubt. astonished / taken aback = very surprised
    healer = a person who treats or cures illness
Board Pattern Questions Mapped to Exam Format
Short Answer 2 marks
What two further details do Har Datt and Dev Datt give? 2 Marks
How to answer: Name the physical detail and the health problem.
View Answer Hide Answer

Answer: Har Datt says the camel has a short tail, and Dev Datt says it is suffering from pain in the stomach.

Longer Short Answer 3 marks
Why does the Merchant first think Dev Datt may be a healer? 3 Marks
How to answer: Connect Dev Datt’s exact knowledge with the camel’s illness.
View Answer Hide Answer

Answer: Dev Datt correctly identifies a stomach pain that the camel has suffered for two weeks. The Merchant cannot imagine that a traveller could know this from tracks, so he assumes Dev Datt must be a healer who can diagnose and cure the animal.

Remove Ads
CA Maninder Singh's photo - Co-founder, Teachoo

Made by

CA Maninder Singh

CA Maninder Singh is a Chartered Accountant with 16+ years of practical experience and 20+ years of teaching experience. At Teachoo, he simplifies Accounts, Tax and GST with step-by-step examples so students can apply concepts confidently in exams and real life.

For an uninterrupted learning experience, students can use Teachoo Black to remove ads and focus better.