Covers all CBSE Q10 patterns (questions 13–17) and all Q11 patterns (questions 18–21). In the exam: answer any ONE Q10 and any ONE Q11, in about 100–120 words each.

13. Examine the similarities and differences between Avva and the old lady in Triveni's Kashi Yatre .

Is question ka jawab story se directly connect hota hai. Short aur clear likho — 2-3 sentences kaafi hain.

How to answer: Give two or more similarities AND two or more differences, each with textual support; close with a connecting insight. 100-120 words.
View Answer Hide Answer
Both are elderly women driven by a strong inner wish, and both show dignity and strength of character. The old lady in Kashi Yatre longs to visit Kashi but gives away her savings for an orphan girl's wedding, sacrificing her own dream for another. Avva, by contrast, claims something for herself: the right to read and be independent. Where the fictional lady acts selflessly outward, Avva acts courageously inward. Yet both prove that true strength lies not in circumstances but in the choices a person makes despite them.

Kashi Yatre wali budhiya ne apni savings ek garib ladki ki shaadi mein de di — apna lifelong Kashi jaane ka sapna chod diya. Yeh selflessness aur compassion dikhata hai. Short mein: desire sacrifice ki real purity se zyada important hai.

14. ‘How I Taught My Grandmother to Read’ and ‘A Letter to God’ deal with the themes of faith and transformation. Discuss.

Is question ka jawab story se directly connect hota hai. Short aur clear likho — 2-3 sentences kaafi hain.

How to answer: Name both themes, show how EACH text handles EACH theme, then state the key difference. 100-120 words.
View Answer Hide Answer
In both stories an unshakeable belief drives the character. Avva believes in herself and in learning; at sixty-two she masters the alphabet and is transformed from a dependent woman into an independent reader. Lencho, in ‘A Letter to God’, has absolute faith in God and, after the storm ruins his crop, is transformed from despair to renewed hope. The difference lies in the source: Avva's faith is inward and rewarded by her own effort, while Lencho's is outward and divine, with help arriving through others' unseen kindness. Both prove conviction can change a life.

Is question ka jawab story se directly connect hota hai. Short aur clear likho — 2-3 sentences kaafi hain. Exact text ke words use karo.

15. Compare ‘How I Taught My Grandmother to Read’ and ‘Iswaran the Storyteller’. Examine how both show that storytelling can transform those who listen.
How to answer: Discuss each text separately, then compare; tie both back to the storytelling claim. 100-120 words.
View Answer Hide Answer
In ‘How I Taught My Grandmother to Read’, Avva's deep connection to the serial Kashi Yatre drives her to achieve literacy at sixty-two; the story she could only hear becomes the reason she learns to read. In ‘Iswaran the Storyteller’, Iswaran's vivid ghost story so grips the rational Mahendra that he is reduced to terror, imagining a ghost outside his window. In both, a told story reshapes the listener's world - one transforming a life positively towards independence, the other altering perception through fear. Together they show storytelling is never passive: it acts powerfully on those who listen.

Kashi Yatre wali budhiya ne apni savings ek garib ladki ki shaadi mein de di — apna lifelong Kashi jaane ka sapna chod diya. Yeh selflessness aur compassion dikhata hai. Short mein: desire sacrifice ki real purity se zyada important hai.

16. Analyse how Avva in ‘How I Taught My Grandmother to Read’ and Amanda in ‘Amanda!’ both yearn for independence, though they express it differently.
How to answer: Analyse HOW each character expresses the same yearning; bring out the contrast in their outcomes. 100-120 words.
View Answer Hide Answer
Avva's yearning is practical and urgent: she feels “dependent and helpless,” openly declares “I want to be independent,” and acts on it through daily, disciplined study until she can read alone - her independence is achieved in reality. Amanda's yearning is internal and imaginative: nagged constantly, she escapes into fantasies of being a mermaid, an orphan or Rapunzel, figures free from control - her independence stays a daydream. Both reveal the same human need for freedom, but Avva claims it through effort while Amanda can only imagine it, showing how circumstances decide whether a yearning is fulfilled or suppressed.

Kashi Yatre wali budhiya ne apni savings ek garib ladki ki shaadi mein de di — apna lifelong Kashi jaane ka sapna chod diya. Yeh selflessness aur compassion dikhata hai. Short mein: desire sacrifice ki real purity se zyada important hai.

17. How does Avva's method of learning (self-motivated, deadline-driven, intensive daily practice) contrast with the narrator's assumption that age makes learning impossible? Examine how this contrast reshapes the narrator's view of human potential.

Is question ka jawab story se directly connect hota hai. Short aur clear likho — 2-3 sentences kaafi hain.

How to answer: Address the contrast (assumption versus method) AND its effect on the narrator. 100-120 words.
View Answer Hide Answer
The narrator listed age-related limitations - grey hair, wrinkled hands, spectacles, kitchen work - as proof that learning was impossible. Avva's method was the exact opposite: self-motivated and intensive, she read, wrote and recited every single day with full focus, fixing Saraswati Puja as a personal deadline. The contrast is stark: passive assumption versus active discipline. As Avva's effort produced real results, the narrator had to revise every assumption about age and ability. This reshaped her sense of human potential so deeply that it planted the seeds of her own teaching career, proving determination outweighs circumstance.

concentration = focus — poora dhyan ek jagah lagana. Avva aise hi Kashi Yatre sunti thi: 'with the greatest concentration.'

18. Evaluate how the story is a lesson in the value of education for personal independence.
How to answer: Evaluate HOW effectively it argues - cost, effort, reward; use the key quote; do not just retell the plot.
View Answer Hide Answer
The story argues for education through feeling, not theory, which makes it effective. It first shows the cost of illiteracy: Avva rubbing the pages helplessly, weeping alone, “dependent and helpless” despite her wealth. Her question, “What use is money when I cannot be independent?”, makes the reader feel illiteracy as a loss of selfhood. Then comes the effort: reading, writing and reciting daily for months at sixty-two. Finally the reward, on Dassara, is not just reading a novel but restored dignity and freedom. By showing rather than preaching, the story proves education is not a skill but a form of independence.

Effect: usne apne bacchon aur pote-potiyon ko achhe se padhai karwai. Apna regret next generation tak nahi pahunchne diya — yahi uski strength hai.

19. Evaluate how the story critiques the social norm that denied education to girls in earlier times.
How to answer: State WHAT is critiqued, HOW it is shown, and the author's implied conclusion. 100-120 words.
View Answer Hide Answer
The critique comes not through argument but through Avva's own quiet words: “In those days people never considered education essential for girls.” This single line exposes a whole social attitude that robbed an intelligent woman of literacy. Sudha Murty shows the cost vividly - Avva, capable enough to memorise entire episodes by ear, was denied the simple ability to read. The author's implied conclusion is powerful: the deprivation was society's failure, not Avva's. The irony sharpens it - denied education herself, Avva ensured every child studied well, becoming the very change society had refused her. The critique is gentle yet devastating.

Yeh vocabulary match question hai. Story se seedha: protagonist = main character, convincing = believable, episode = ek serial ka hissa. Dictionary ki zaroorat nahi — story mein in words ke exact meanings mile hain.

20. How does Avva's quiet dignity and determination transform the narrator from a dismissive child into a dedicated teacher? Elucidate.
How to answer: Show the transformation step by step: the narrator's initial state, what changed her, and the result.
View Answer Hide Answer
When Avva announced her plan, the twelve-year-old narrator mocked her, listing her grey hair and wrinkled hands. But Avva did not argue; she simply smiled and said, “For learning there is no age bar.” This calm dignity disarmed the narrator, who could not refuse someone who answered ridicule with such conviction, so she began to teach. As Avva worked with extraordinary discipline, reading and reciting every day, the narrator's scorn turned to admiration. By Dassara she understood she had been given a gift: a first student who made her, for life, a teacher.

True — Avva ne khud 62 saal mein yeh prove kiya. Uska exact quote hai: 'For learning there is no age bar.' Board exam mein yeh quote hamesha likho.

21. Discuss how the story depicts the way denial of literacy leads to dependence, emotional vulnerability and a loss of personal dignity.
How to answer: Trace the cause (denied schooling) to its effects (dependence, vulnerability, lost dignity) through specific incidents.
View Answer Hide Answer
The story traces the consequences of Avva's illiteracy with painful clarity. The cause is plain: denied schooling as a girl, she never learned to read. The effects unfold step by step - she cannot read the magazine she loves; she is too ashamed to ask anyone for help; she feels “dependent and helpless” despite being financially comfortable. Her tears when the narrator returns reveal the depth of this emotional vulnerability, and her famous question, “What use is money when I cannot be independent?”, shows how illiteracy stripped her of dignity. Sudha Murty depicts illiteracy not as a mere inconvenience but as a deprivation of selfhood.

Effect: usne apne bacchon aur pote-potiyon ko achhe se padhai karwai. Apna regret next generation tak nahi pahunchne diya — yahi uski strength hai.

Remove Ads
Maninder Singh's photo - Co-founder, Teachoo

Made by

Maninder Singh

CA Maninder Singh is a Chartered Accountant with 16+ years of practical experience and 20+ years of teaching experience. He teaches Science, Economics, Accounting and English at Teachoo using clear explanations and exam-focused methods students can trust.

For faster and distraction-free study, students can choose Teachoo Black.