Example of Tax Planning
-ex-
Suppose a person has business income of 350000
Tax Applicable on it is 6180 as shown below
Particulars | Amount |
Income | 350000 |
Tax | 8000 |
Rebate | 2000 |
Net Tax | 6000 |
Cess | 180 |
Total Tax | 6180 |
He does tax planning and shows salary of his wife working in his office at Rs 120000
Hence his net business income =350000-120000=230000
Income of wife-120000 which is also tax free
Mr A | Mrs A | |||
Particulars | Amount | Particulars | Amount | |
Income | 230000 | Income | 1200000 | |
Tax | 0 | Tax | 0 | |
Rebate | 0 | Rebate | 0 | |
Net Tax | 0 | Net Tax | 0 | |
Cess | 0 | Cess | 0 | |
Total Tax | 0 | Total Tax | 0 |
Tax Saved=6180
To prevent such tax planning,this section has been introduced
and now income of spouse will be clubbed with income of person as shown below
Particulars | Amount |
Income of Mr A | 230000 |
Add | |
Income of Mrs B Clubbed | 120000 |
Total Income | 350000 |
Tax | 8000 |
Rebate | 2000 |
Net Tax | 6000 |
Cess | 180 |
Total Tax | 6180 |
-eex-
As per Section 64(!)
If a person has substantial interest in a concern and spouse receives salary/ remuneration from it, then salary/remuneration of spouse will be clubbed in hands of person having substantial interest.
Exception
No clubbing done if
the spouse has required technical professional qualification
And
Income solely attributed to such technical professional qualification
What is Substantial Interest
It means
In Case of | Meaning of Substantial Interest |
Company (Private Limited/Limited Company) |
Person Holds 20% or more voting power |
Other than Company (Proprietorship/partnership) |
Person entitled for 20% or more profit share |
Note:-
- Beneficial Ownership is Important [Not Actual Ownership]
i.e. person in whose name shares are registered
- Share of wife & relatives also included while calculating 20% limit
- Relative means Wife / Brother/ Sister / linear ascendant( parents)/ Linear Descendants (Children )
- (Brother in Law / Sister in Law Not Covered)
EXAM QUESTION
During the previous year 2015-16, the following transactions occurred in respect of Mr. A.
Mr. A holds 75% share in a partnership firm. Mrs. A received a commission of Rs 25,000 from the firm for promoting the sales of the firm. Mrs. A possesses no technical or professional qualification
View AnswerSince person has more than 20% profit share, he is deemed to be having substantial interest
Also
Mrs. A possesses no technical or professional qualification
Hence income will be clubbed
-ea-
Both Husband & Wife Have Substantial Interest
- Income clubbed in the Hands of person having higher total income [Without including such remuneration]
- If once clubbed in one person hand, every year clubbed in same hand.
- However AO can club in other person hands after giving opportunity of being heard.
Note :-
In the above case, Clubbing shall start from previous year when all 3 below conditions satisfied
(a) Both husband wife have substantial interest
(b) Both are getting remuneration
(c) Both are husband / wife at time of earning income [accrual of income]