You are here
Extract from the Story
"'Yes, I need your help. You know when you were away, Karmaveera came as usual. I opened the magazine. I saw the picture that accompanies the story of Kashi Yatre and I could not understand anything that was written. Many times I rubbed my hands over the pages wishing they could understand what was written... I could have asked somebody in this village but I was too embarrassed to do so. I felt very dependent and helpless. We are well-off, but what use is money when I cannot be independent?'
'I have decided I want to learn the Kannada alphabet from tomorrow onwards. I will work very hard. I will keep Saraswati Puja day during Dassara as the deadline. That day I should be able to read a novel on my own. I want to be independent.'"
'I have decided I want to learn the Kannada alphabet from tomorrow onwards. I will work very hard. I will keep Saraswati Puja day during Dassara as the deadline. That day I should be able to read a novel on my own. I want to be independent.'"
Summary in Bullet Points
- While the narrator was away, Karmaveera arrived as usual.
- Avva opened it and saw the picture, but could not read a word.
- It hurt her immensely . immensely = extremely; to a very great degree
- She was too embarrassed to ask anyone else to read it for her. embarrassed = feeling ashamed or awkward about something, especially in front of others
- Though the family was well-off , she felt dependent and helpless. well-off = financially comfortable; having enough money to live comfortably
- She asked: “What use is money when I cannot be independent ?” independent = able to do things yourself without needing help from others; self-reliant
- Avva decided to learn the Kannada alphabet from the very next day.
- She set Saraswati Puja during Dassara as her deadline . Saraswati Puja = a Hindu festival honouring Saraswati, the goddess of learning and knowledge.
- Celebrated during Dassara Dassara = a major Hindu festival celebrated in autumn, lasting ten days deadline = a fixed date or time by which something must be completed .
- Her goal: to read a novel on her own by that day.
- The narrator saw her determination . determination = a firm decision to do something no matter how difficult it seems; strong willpower
- But she childishly laughed at Avva's age (62). childishly = in an immature, thoughtless way.
- As a child would behave.
NCERT Questions (from the Textbook)
Critical Reflection — Extract 1 (NCERT Kaveri pages 10–12)
The Critical Reflection extract ("When I came back to my village…") is from Part II. See Critical Reflection
Board Pattern
Questions Mapped to Exam Format
Fill in the Blank (Bracket Choice)
1 mark - 1 sentence only
Avva felt __________ (independent / helpless) when she opened the magazine and could not read a single word.
How to answer:
Start with the key word from the question. Support your answer with specific details from the story. Write in complete sentences.
View Answer
helpless
helpless = unable to do something on your own; completely dependent on others for a basic task
Why: Avva's own words are "I felt very dependent and helpless." She could not read what was written and was too embarrassed to ask for help.
helpless = unable to do something on your own; completely dependent on others for a basic task
Why: Avva's own words are "I felt very dependent and helpless." She could not read what was written and was too embarrassed to ask for help.
Explanation:
The emotion is "helpless + dependent". Use both words. Then link to the paradox: wealthy but still powerless. That contrast is the whole point of her famous line.
Avva ka self-respect itna zyada tha ki kisi se poochh hi nahi saki. 'I was too embarrassed' — yeh pride aur dignity show karta hai. False hai ki usne kisi se maanga — story clearly kehti hai usne nahi maanga.
MCQ. What Justifies Statement (1 mark)
Which of the following options best justifies Avva's statement "What use is money when I cannot be independent?"
How to answer:
Start with the key word from the question. Support your answer with specific details from the story. Write in complete sentences.
View Answer
Answer: (B)
- Avva clarifies herself: the family was "well-off" but she still could not read a magazine alone.
Money could not replace literacy.
Her statement is about how financial wealth means nothing without knowledge-based independence.
Money could not replace literacy.
Her statement is about how financial wealth means nothing without knowledge-based independence.
Avva ka seedha point: paisa sab kuch nahi deta. Real independence sirf padh-likh ke milti hai. Exam mein yeh quote zaroor use karo: 'What use is money when I cannot be independent?'
Short Answer. What Character Reveals (1 mark)
Avva was "too embarrassed" to ask someone in the village to read for her.
What does this tell us about her character?
How to answer:
Start with the key word from the question. Support your answer with specific details from the story. Write in complete sentences.
View Answer
It shows Avva’s strong self-respect. Admitting she could not read would feel humiliating, so she chose to learn herself rather than ask for help.
Avva ka self-respect itna zyada tha ki kisi se poochh hi nahi saki. 'I was too embarrassed' — yeh pride aur dignity show karta hai. False hai ki usne kisi se maanga — story clearly kehti hai usne nahi maanga.
Short Answer. Elaborate (2 marks)
According to the extract, what did Avva realise when she opened the magazine?
Elaborate on the emotion behind her words.
How to answer:
Start with the key word from the question. Support your answer with specific details from the story. Write in complete sentences.
View Answer
Opening Karmaveera, Avva could see the picture but not read a word of the story she loved.
She rubbed the pages helplessly, feeling dependent and helpless. Painful because, though well-off, money could not give her literacy.
She rubbed the pages helplessly, feeling dependent and helpless. Painful because, though well-off, money could not give her literacy.
Avva khud ko novel ki protagonist se relate karti thi — dono elderly women thi aur dono kabhi Kashi nahi gayi thi. Yeh personal connection tha, entertainment nahi.
Short Answer (3 marks) - 40–50 words
Why is Avva's decision to learn to read at age 62 significant? What does it reveal about her character and the story's central message?
How to answer:
Start with the key word from the question. Support your answer with specific details from the story. Write in complete sentences.
View Answer
Avva’s decision is significant because it springs from personal reckoning, not pressure. She realised wealth without literacy was meaningless. It reveals courage at 62, self-awareness (“I want to be independent”), and determination. Choosing Saraswati Puja as her deadline shows she treated learning as sacred.
Explanation:
Q8 needs: what the decision reveals (courage, dignity) + the specific evidence from the text (Saraswati Puja deadline, the quote).
Avva ka seedha point: paisa sab kuch nahi deta. Real independence sirf padh-likh ke milti hai. Exam mein yeh quote zaroor use karo: 'What use is money when I cannot be independent?'
