Check sibling questions

 [Section 65B(44)]

Service means

  any activity for consideration

  carried out by a person for another and

  includes a declared service.

 

Service shall not include

  • Sale/Gift etc of Immoveable property
  • Sale/delivery/supply of goods ( moveable Property)
  • Transaction in money/actionable claim*
  • Service from employee to employer
  • Court fees  

 

Also it has provided in Explanation 1,that

  1. Functions of   MP/MLA/Municipal Councillor etc not considwered service
  2. Duty performed by any person who holds a constituitional post is not regarded as service

Analysis

  • Hence, Activity should be carried out for consideration. If not carried out for consideration, then not considered a service and no service tax will be levied on it
  • Only service carried out from one person to another covered, service to self not covered
  • (For example-No service tax on service provided to own branch)
  • It includes a declared service. Declared service means 9 services which have been specified in Section66E) Service tax will be levied on these.
    • For example Renting of Immoveable Property.These will be studied in detail in CA Final)

 

 

QUESTIONS  

Q1 What is actionable claim? Whether Service tax applicable on it?

View answer

Actionable Claim means

Claim to unsecured debt (secured debt not covered)

Or

Claim to any beneficial interest in moveable property

 

Examples of Actionable Claim

  • A takes loan from B. B has actionable claim on A
  • A takes loan from B on security of his house. Since loan is secured, B does not have actionable claim
  • C manufactures goods as per directions of A, A has beneficial interest in goods, hence it is an actionable claim

 No Service tax applicable on actionalble claim as it is not considered service

AMENDMENT

 We know that Service does not include transactions in money or actionable claim

As per Newly inserted Explanation 2,

“transaction in money or actionable claim” shall not include––

1. Activity relating to use of money or its conversion from one form to another (Example- Money Changer Service )

2.Activity for FACILITATION OF transaction in money or actionable claim like

  • l ottery distributor/Selling Agent of Lottery on behalf of Central Govt in relation to promotion,,marketing,selling of lottery or facilitating in organising lottery of any kind, in any other manner, in accordance with the provisions of the Lotteries (Regulation) Act, 1998.”(New Amendment)
  • Chit fund (Foreman of Chit fund)

Hence, service tax will be imposed on Money changer service,lottery service/chit fuind service and it cannot be said that these are transaction in money/actionable claim and hence not taxable

 

Relevant Definitins:-

“Foreman of chit fund

shall have the same meaning as is assigned to the term
foreman in clause (j) of section 2 of the Chit Funds Act, 1982

 

“Lottery distributor or selling agent means

a person appointed or authorised by a State

for the purposes of promoting, marketing, selling or facilitating in organising lottery of any kind, in any manner,

organised by such State in accordance with the
provisions of the Lotteries (Regulation) Act, 1998.”

 

 

Q2 Whether Service tax applicable on Salary to Employees?

View answer

If employees working on payroll of company,

no service tax as a provision of service by an employee to the employer is not a service

 

If employees working on contract,it can be either

1.Direct Contract-

Person has direct contract with company. In this case,service tax is applicable, as that person is not technically an employee

 

2.Third Party Contract

Person works for third party agency on payroll and third party agency has contract with company

In this case, service tax is applicable on contract of third party with company. However no service tax on contract of person with third party agency.

 

3.Service of daily wager

No service tax on daily wager, as he is also a employee. No service tax on temporary employees also, as these also not considered a service.

 

Q3

Mention briefly the specific exclusions from the definition of the term 'service' as provided in section 65B(44) of the Finance Act, 1994. 

View answer

Service shall not include

  • Sale/Gift etc of Immovable property
  • Sale/delivery/supply of goods ( movable Property)
  • Transaction in money/actionable claim*
  • Service from employee to employer
  • Court fees  

Also it has provided in Explanation 1,that

Functions of MP/MLA/Municipal Councillor etc not considered service

Duty performed by any person who holds a constitutional post is not regarded as service

  1. Service Tax
  2. Basic Concepts of Service Tax

About the Author

CA Maninder Singh

CA Maninder Singh is a Chartered Accountant for the past 14 years. He also provides Accounts Tax GST Training in Delhi, Kerala and online.